Your bestselling product and the best product to advertise aren't necessarily the same thing.
It's understandable to put budget behind what already sells. But sales volume alone doesn't tell me whether a product deserves more advertising spend.
A bestseller might be popular with existing customers. It might attract strong organic demand or be something people add to a larger order. None of that necessarily makes it the strongest product for winning new customers at the most competitive time of year.
Black Friday sharpens the problem. Once you add a discount and the increasing cost of advertising, a product generating impressive sales can leave far less profit than you expected. Revenue can look great on the platform, while profit quietly shrinks.
So, before I increase budget, I want to know what the business actually keeps from those sales, whether customers buy anything else and whether there's evidence they come back.
Repeat purchases aren't essential. A product that mainly attracts one-time buyers can still be worth advertising if that single purchase is profitable enough. I just wouldn't justify its acquisition cost with an optimistic assumption about what customers might do next.
Stock matters too. There's little value in building your plan around a bestseller if the popular sizes or variants won't be available when demand peaks.
Data is everything. Let previous performance guide your decisions rather than your favourite product or a guess at what might sell. Last year's data is a far better starting point than instinct.
None of this means bestsellers are poor choices. They are often the right horse to back as you head into peak. The point is that deciding what to advertise, and how heavily, is part of managing advertising well. Sometimes a product deserves a place in the strategy with controlled spend rather than an ever-increasing budget. A carefully chosen bundle or entry-level product can also make a stronger offer than the usual bestseller. Make sure you know what the right choice is for your business this Q4.
Subscribe to my email newsletter for the real examples and the thinking behind these decisions, including when a runaway bestseller didn’t need more budget, it needed more control…

.png)
Comments